DEI Policy: What Small Businesses Need to Know

Business owners and managers are faced with many daunting tasks, and one of them is staying informed about evolving regulations. Recently, there have been notable shifts in federal policies concerning diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives. Understanding these changes and their potential impact is crucial for small-to-medium sized businesses.

The Federal Government's Position

The federal government recently released two executive orders that impact businesses, “Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs And Preferencing,” and “Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity.” The impetus behind these policy adjustments stems from a focus on ensuring equal opportunity and merit-based principles across the nation.  

The federal government has expressed the belief that longstanding civil rights laws protect individuals from discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, and these protections should serve as the foundation for equality of opportunity.  

The stated goal is to end what the administration views as discriminatory preferences and to promote individual initiative, excellence, and hard work. This includes a directive to terminate policies and programs that may employ illegal preferences, mandates, or activities related to DEI. The objective is to ensure that opportunities are based on qualifications rather than demographic considerations. Furthermore, there is a stated aim to ensure that taxpayer resources are expended effectively and without supporting programs deemed discriminatory.

Understanding Implementation and Observance

In response to these policy shifts, federal agencies are taking steps to review and revise existing practices. This includes terminating programs, mandates, policies, and activities related to DEI and DEIA (diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility) within the federal government.  

Federal employment practices are being reviewed and adjusted to eliminate DEI or DEIA factors. Federal contractors and subcontractors are also under scrutiny, with requirements related to affirmative action being ceased. Moving forward, federal contracts may include terms requiring contractors to certify their compliance with these newly implemented orders.

For small businesses, this evolving landscape necessitates a careful review of current DEI-related programs, policies, and training materials, especially for those engaged with the federal government as a contractor or as a grant recipient. Additionally, the federal government intends to enforce civil rights laws against DEI programs it deems discriminatory in the private sector. This is where the orders could impact many small-to-mediums sized businesses.

Implications for Employees

Employees may experience a shift in workplace focus towards individual merit and qualifications. Some employees may welcome this renewed emphasis, believing it fosters a fairer environment based on their skills and contributions. However, others may have concerns about the potential impact on inclusivity efforts and whether these changes will affect opportunities for underrepresented groups.  

Clear and transparent internal communication will be vital to address any uncertainty and maintain a positive work environment during this period of policy adjustments. Businesses can emphasize broader workplace values such as respect, fairness, and professional growth to foster inclusivity while aligning with the new federal direction. In the larger corporate world, Microsoft, Costco, and Amazon have all taken different approaches to balance their business needs, the needs of their employees, and the changing regulatory landscape.

Implications for Owners and Managers

Business owners and managers will play a critical role in navigating these changes. To comply with the federal order, steps might include:

• Reviewing existing DEI policies and programs to ensure compliance with federal anti-discrimination laws. This includes examining hiring practices, promotion criteria, and training materials.
• Ensuring hiring and promotion decisions are explicitly based on skills, qualifications, and merit rather than demographic quotas or preferences.
• Staying informed about updates to federal regulations and guidance related to DEI.
• Communicating clearly with employees about any policy changes and the continued commitment to a fair and respectful workplace.
• Consulting with legal professionals to ensure that workplace policies align with all relevant laws and to mitigate potential legal risks.

It's important to note that while the federal focus is shifting, private businesses generally retain the discretion to continue DEI efforts as long as they are structured to avoid legal risk and workplace division.

Orders Under Preliminary Injunction

Complicating this regulatory process, a federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction blocking key parts of the federal government's executive orders. This injunction means that, at least for the short term, some of the directives, such as terminating "equity-related grants or contracts" and requiring federal contractors to certify they do not operate DEI programs under threat of False Claims Act liability, are on hold. The judge cited concerns about potential violations of free speech and due process rights, finding the orders to be potentially vague and threatening.

However, this is a preliminary ruling, and the federal government is appealing the decision, indicating that the legal challenges to these executive orders will continue and could ultimately reach the Supreme Court. Therefore, while the injunction provides a temporary reprieve, businesses should still remain vigilant and prepared for potential future changes in federal policy.

Conclusion

The landscape of federal DEI policies is evolving, and these changes have the potential to impact small-to-medium sized businesses, particularly those involved in federal contracting or with established DEI initiatives. By understanding the stated intent behind these policy shifts, taking legally necessary steps to review and adjust internal practices, and staying informed about ongoing developments like the preliminary injunction, your business can navigate these changes effectively and maintain compliance.

Stay Ahead with Future Systems

Keep your business compliant with the latest federal regulations and follow the Future Systems blog for timely updates and insightful analysis. We are committed to providing you with the information you need to succeed in a dynamic regulatory environment.